Okay, are we asking too much here? Pencils that go on, don’t run and smear and draw on easily without pulling your eyelids. Is that too much to ask? By far the hardest makeup item to find, but try “Makeup Forever” in #25. It’s is a bit pricey, around $18 I think, for a pencil, but it’s super long and lasts forever. And it’s a warm brown that I use for everything, brows, eyelids, lip liner. A great cost-effective alernative is Wet & Wild’s soft brown eyebrow pencil. Super long and only 99c.